Top Hotels in Cape May for Unforgettable Stays

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Adham Koenderink

Updated: 25 February 2024 · 3 min

Nestled along the picturesque coastline of New Jersey, Cape May stands as a beacon of hospitality, boasting a rich history and a unique blend of charm and elegance. This quaint, Victorian-era town is not just renowned for its beautiful beaches and stunning sunsets but also for its exceptional accommodations. For those planning a visit, discovering the best hotels in Cape May is essential to experiencing the full splendor and comfort this seaside gem has to offer.

From boutique inns that whisper stories of yesteryears to modern luxury retreats that cater to every conceivable comfort, Cape May's hotel scene is as diverse as it is exquisite. Each hotel offers guests a unique window into the soul of this historic beach town, combining top-notch services with a touch of local flavor. Whether you're seeking a romantic getaway, a family vacation, or a solo adventure, the right hotel can significantly enhance your Cape May experience, making it truly unforgettable.

In this article, we'll take you through a curated selection of the best hotels in Cape May, focusing on their distinctive features, premier amenities, and the unparalleled hospitality they offer. Our recommendations are crafted to help travelers of all tastes and budgets find their perfect stay. Here, comfort meets elegance, setting the stage for memories that will last a lifetime. So, pack your bags and prepare to be swept away by the charm and luxury of Cape May's finest accommodations.
Show more + Show less -

Our Top 5

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. Beach Shack
2. Congress Hall
3. La Mer Beachfront Resort
4. Southern Mansion
5. The Queen Victoria

Best Luxury Hotels in Cape May

Check Availability

Cape May
Sep 26, 2026 - Sep 27, 2026

Beach Shack

8.7

Good

(176 Reviews)

+ 91 photos
For a laid-back beachside experience, The Beach Shack offers the perfect mix of casual comfort and seaside charm. This hotel is ideal for families and couples alike, featuring easy beach access, a heated pool, and the popular Rusty Nail Beach Bar and Grill. Rooms are designed with a beachy flair, ensuring a relaxing vibe that complements the scenic surroundings. The Beach Shack's fire pits and live entertainment elevate the beach experience, making it a unique choice for those aiming to enjoy Cape May's coastal beauty fully.
Address: 205 Beach Avenue
Rating: Good 8.7 (176 Reviews)
Rooms: 74
Price: From 118$

Congress Hall

9.0

Good

(337 Reviews)

+ 91 photos
Situated in the heart of Cape May stands as a testament to luxury and elegance. Established in 1816, this historic hotel not only boasts a rich history but offers a truly luxurious experience. It captures the essence of a bygone era through its Victorian architecture while providing guests with all modern comforts. The hotel's spacious, opulently decorated rooms, world-class spa, and fine dining options make it a top choice for those seeking the best hotels in Cape May. Overlooking the Atlantic Ocean, guests can enjoy stunning vistas, exceptional service, and activities that cater to every interest, making it a quintessential retreat for luxury seekers.
Address: 200 Congress Place
Rating: Good 9.0 (337 Reviews)
Rooms: 108
Price: From 956$

Best Beachfront Hotels in Cape May

The allure of Cape May's beaches is undeniable, and there's no better way to experience the seaside charm than by staying right on the waterfront. This section highlights the best hotels in Cape May that offer direct beach access, stunning ocean views, and a refreshing ambiance. These hotels not only provide the convenience of stepping out onto the sandy shores from your doorstep but also ensure each moment of your stay is soaked in the serene beauty of the Atlantic. From sunrise swims to sunset strolls, these beachfront hotels are perfect for ocean lovers looking for a memorable stay.

La Mer Beachfront Resort

8.5

Good

(350 Reviews)

+ 91 photos
La Mer Beachfront Resort encapsulates the beauty and tranquility of Cape May's shoreline. With its prime beachfront location, guests have unrivaled access to the beach, along with luxurious accommodations that offer panoramic ocean views. The resort provides an array of amenities, including a private beach, outdoor pool, and on-site dining, blending convenience with luxury. Each room is elegantly furnished, ensuring a comfortable and peaceful stay. La Mer Beachfront Resort's emphasis on privacy and pampering makes it a standout among the best hotels in Cape May for a serene beach getaway.
Address: 1317 Beach Avenue
Rating: Good 8.5 (350 Reviews)
Rooms: 120
Price: From 105$

Southern Mansion

8.6

Good

(24 Reviews)

+ 26 photos
Built in 1863, The Southern Mansion is an architectural marvel that offers an intimate boutique hotel experience. This award-winning hotel is set within acres of manicured gardens, exuding privacy and tranquility amidst the bustling beach town. Each room is uniquely decorated, blending historical elegance with modern luxury, featuring antique furnishings and plush comforts. The Southern Mansion is renowned for its attentive service, gourmet breakfast, and serene atmosphere, making it a standout among the best hotels in Cape May for those in search of opulence and exclusivity.
Address: 720 Washington Street
Rating: Good 8.6 (24 Reviews)
Rooms: 24
Price: From 399$

Best Family-Friendly Hotels in Cape May

For families traveling to Cape May, finding accommodations that cater to both adults and children is crucial. A section dedicated to the best family-friendly hotels in Cape May could provide valuable insights for parents looking to balance relaxation with family fun. Hotels offering kid-friendly amenities like pools, game rooms, and proximity to Cape May's beaches and attractions, such as the Sandpiper Beach Club or the Montreal Beach Resort, known for its family-oriented services and accommodations, would be highlighted here.

The Queen Victoria

9.0

Good

(33 Reviews)

+ 91 photos
The Queen Victoria combines the charm of a bed and breakfast with the luxury of a boutique hotel. It is known for its stunning Victorian architecture, elegant rooms, and exceptional service. Each room is meticulously designed to offer a unique stay, with period furnishings and modern amenities. Guests can enjoy a sumptuous breakfast, afternoon tea, and countless cozy nooks perfect for relaxing. Located just a short walk from Cape May's picturesque beaches and historic district, The Queen Victoria offers a luxurious escape in the very heart of the town, standing out as a premier destination for those seeking the best hotels in Cape May.
Address: 102 Ocean Street
Rating: Good 9.0 (33 Reviews)
Rooms: 31
Price: From 294$